In The Spotlight

Boxing vs Street Fighting

3 replies
Joined: 2007-02-20
Points: 7
User offline. Last seen 39 years 2 weeks ago.

Hi there. Now, please understand — I don’t mean this as a ‘which do you consider superior?’ sort of question, I’d simply like to discuss the practicalities of boxing under conditions such as a mugging, other form of street attack, etc. (I don’t advocate streetfighting in any way whatsoever, except perhaps the game.)

I read this quote on another site and it drives home what I wanted to ask in this topic:

In the modern sport of “non-contact” karate there is no real incentive for a subject to adopt a realistic fighting stance when his worst–case scenario is merely to have an ippon scored against him. Generally, competition stances tend to be higher.

Why do so many competition fighters rise up and try to score over the top of their opponent’s guard? Because they know they are safe from being stabbed in the belly or the groin by their opponents. How do they know? Because they are protected by the rules! 

 

 

 

 

The whole boxing stance, the guards, bobbing and weaving away from counterattacks, and so forth all come from amateur/professional boxing where rules dictate that you can only land blows to your opponent’s face and torso — nothing below the belt, no kicks, no wrestling–style grapples, etc. In a ‘real–life’ situation, how would a boxer counter something as simple as a swift kick to the nuts or knees?

Joined: 2005-03-12
Points: 111
User offline. Last seen 8 hours 36 min ago.
well put
Kami, that was well put. Good job. Just want to add something about knife fighting. There are knife fighting methods - basic defensive moves vs offensive moves and vice versa, but generally speaking don't expect to enter a knife fight and not get cut. It is inevitable, and basically a matter of who can subdue who first. Street fights, in general, are much the same. It is not a boxing match and there are no rules. Yes, boxing helps prepare your mind and body, but the strategy is completely different. If it happens and is completely unavoidable (which in most cases I believe it is...), then you have one objective -- incapacitate your opponent before he incapacitates you. Period. And don't stop incapacitating until you know for damn sure he isn't getting up again...
Joined: 2007-02-21
Points: 3
User offline. Last seen 47 weeks 2 days ago.
Still, there is a lot more
Still, there is a lot more discipline in boxing and if you're a trained boxer being attacked by an unexperienced armed mugger, then you have to take your physical characteristics into effect. If you duck underneath the arc of a bat swing, and pop up just in time to catch him off his guard then you should employ your fists to go to work on him.
Joined: 2006-08-04
Points: 78
User offline. Last seen 38 weeks 22 hours ago.
Hey, admin! "incapacitate

Hey, admin! 

"incapacitate your opponent before he incapacitates you. Period. And don't stop incapacitating until you know for damn sure he isn't getting up again..." Freakin hilarious. I love it.

Just out of curiosity...what happened to my post? Did it get nixed?

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

It's the boxers who attract the real women, after all, with their raw primeval strength, beautifully toned bodies and just a touch of vulnerability.
— Eamonn Mccabe

Recent Readers

Quick Stats

Total Boxers: 6797
Total Boxing Gyms and Trainers: 245